When unethical is ethical

Apparently the ethics commissioner said today that he found nothing unethical in the actions of Emerson and Harper, in regards to Emerson’s party switching. And just yesterday I was speaking with a friend, lamenting that Emerson was definitely unethical. Jeez, that sort of makes me look stupid. Fortunately I make myself look stupid on a regular basis so I can take the hit. I feel bad for the voters from Kingsway/Vancouver though, because I’m sure at least some of them don’t do stupid things on a regular basis. But I digress… Having reconsidered Emerson’s flight, I suppose he wasn’t that unethical afterall. By all accounts:
he isn’t that much of a politician (is that a good thing or a bad thing?)
he isn’t that much concerned with social value issues
he is focused on economic type issues
Emerson’s main line of self-defense boils down to the fact that he thinks that by switching parties he is better serving his constituents, the people of Vancouver and the people of British Columbia.
If you add all of this up, you could say that the voters actually got exactly what they asked for. My understanding is that Emerson has primarily represented himself as described above, so the fact that he is acting on this should surprise no-one.

That’s not to say that Emerson was right to do what he did. I would argue that he isn’t better serving Vancouverites, British Columbians and his constituents, in which case he is actually acting like a jack-ass. But don’t forget: I’ve been wrong before.

  • Mom

    When are you entering politics? You seem to have a lot to say. Which party would you join? Maybe you could start the SMITHITE party! Not a bad idea. Check phone books under SMITH – there’s a lot of us!

  • Chrystal

    Just thought i would finally add in a comment even though the issue is old now. I was a complete idiot for voting for Emerson as that was my riding and as a person who did vote i had the complete displeasure of finally learning what democracy means. It was bothersome to know how little my vote didn’t count. What worries me the most is how arrogant the man is…i didn’t vote for him, i voted for the party based on not wanting a conservative majority and felt that would be achieved in my riding. I could care less why he thinks he is in power but i can surmise that the vancouver kigsway riding wanted a liberal….at least that was what the majority said. Now i’m ranting and it’s night shift so have a great day.

  • http://www.pm.gc.ca/ Heathen Sharper

    You do not yet realize your importance. You have only begun to discover you power. Join me and I will complete your training. With our combined strength, we can end this destructive conflict and bring order to the country. If you only knew the power of the dark side. Martin never told you what happened to your social safety net.

    Doug. You can destroy the Liberals. They have foreseen this. It is your destiny. Join me, and we can rule the country as Prime Minister and Very Quiet Minister. Come with me. It’s the only way.

  • sluggo

    Heathen, as it happens I am already a few steps ahead of you in my quest.

    I have assembled an army of super vixens and soldiers because as we know, behind each successul ruler is a nice set and a big gun.

    However, I will not join the shark side. I am using the powers of the force, the schwartz, and SI swimsuit issue. I will crush you and all of the conversatives, neo-liberals and socialist npd’ers. I will become the didi 7 of politics. Mr.Clean. The Tide with Bleach. Nothing can stop me, except for the possible exception of a strong acid such as HCl.

  • Heathen Sharper

    I resist myself to you large super. Acid test complete, it burns.